Your instrument was out of tolerance. What happens next?
An out-of-tolerance notice is not a disaster, but it does start a clock. Here is a practical approach to impact assessment that will stand up to an audit.
Sooner or later, every organisation receives the call: one of your instruments was found out of tolerance during calibration. It is tempting to approve the adjustment, file the certificate and move on. But the out-of-tolerance result raises a question that matters far more than the instrument itself: were the measurements you made with it valid?
Step 1: Understand the size of the error
Start with the as-found data on the certificate. Look at:
- Which functions and ranges were out of tolerance. A multimeter that failed only on its 1,000 V AC range may have been perfectly fine for the 24 V DC measurements you actually make.
- By how much. An error just beyond the limit is very different from one ten times the limit.
- In which direction. A meter reading high might cause good product to be rejected; a meter reading low might cause bad product to be accepted. The consequences are rarely symmetrical.
Step 2: Identify what the instrument was used for
Trace the instrument’s use since its last good calibration. Useful sources include:
- equipment booking or sign-out logs,
- test records or batch records that list the instrument ID,
- calibration records for other instruments that it was used to check,
- the knowledge of the people who use it.
This is where many organisations struggle. If your test records do not capture which instrument was used, an out-of-tolerance result can force a much broader review than would otherwise be needed. It is worth fixing that for the future.
Step 3: Compare the error with your requirements
For each use, ask whether the size of the error could have changed a decision. If the instrument was used to check a parameter with a tolerance of ±5 %, and it was 0.3 % out of its own specification, the measurement was almost certainly still fit for purpose.
If the error is comparable with your product or process tolerance, the measurements need closer review.
Step 4: Decide and act
Possible actions include:
- No action, with a documented justification explaining why the error could not have affected any decision.
- Re-testing retained samples or product still in your control.
- Notifying customers if non-conforming product may have been delivered.
- Reviewing other instruments calibrated using the faulty one.
Step 5: Learn from it
Finally, consider whether the calibration interval should be shortened, whether the instrument should be replaced, or whether handling and storage practices contributed to the failure.
Document everything
ISO 9001:2015 clause 7.1.5.2 requires organisations to determine whether the validity of previous results has been adversely affected and to take appropriate action. ISO/IEC 17025 has similar requirements for laboratories. The record of your assessment, including the reasoning when you conclude no action is needed, is the evidence an auditor will ask to see.
At PME Laboratory, we notify customers of out-of-tolerance results on the day we find them, and include as-found data on every certificate, so you have what you need to start this process straight away.
