All insights
Quality & Compliance4 min read

Pass, fail or indeterminate? Decision rules and guard bands

When a measurement lands close to a tolerance limit, uncertainty decides the verdict. ISO/IEC 17025 now requires labs to say how they make that call.

A calibration result is easy to judge when it lands near the middle of the tolerance band. It is much harder when the reading sits right next to a limit. Because every measurement has uncertainty, there is a zone near each limit where the lab cannot be sure whether the instrument is really in or out of tolerance. How that zone is handled is called the decision rule.

Why this became a requirement

The 2017 revision of ISO/IEC 17025 introduced an explicit requirement: when a laboratory provides a statement of conformity to a specification, it must document the decision rule it uses, take into account the level of risk associated with it, and agree it with the customer. The rule must then be reported on the certificate (clauses 7.1.3 and 7.8.6).

Before this, many labs applied “simple acceptance”: if the reading was inside the limit, the instrument passed, regardless of uncertainty. That approach is still allowed, but it must now be stated and understood.

Simple acceptance

Under simple acceptance (sometimes called shared risk), a result inside the tolerance limit is a pass and outside is a fail. The uncertainty is reported but not used in the decision.

This works well when the uncertainty is small compared with the tolerance, for example at a test uncertainty ratio (TUR) of 4:1 or better. When the TUR is poor, the probability of a wrong decision can be significant.

Guard banding

A guard band shrinks the acceptance zone by a margin, often equal to the expanded uncertainty. A result is only declared a pass if it is inside the tolerance limit by at least that margin.

ILAC-G8:09/2019, Guidelines on Decision Rules and Statements of Conformity, describes several approaches. With a guard band equal to the expanded uncertainty, the probability of falsely accepting a non-conforming instrument is reduced to around 2.5 % or less.

The indeterminate zone

With a guard band in place, results fall into one of four categories:

Result position Statement
Inside limit by more than U Pass
Inside limit by less than U Conditional pass / indeterminate
Outside limit by less than U Conditional fail / indeterminate
Outside limit by more than U Fail

An indeterminate result is not a failure of the calibration. It is an honest statement that the measurement cannot confidently decide either way.

Which rule should you choose?

It depends on the consequences of a wrong decision.

  • For general-purpose instruments with a good TUR, simple acceptance is usually fine.
  • For instruments used in safety-critical, legal or contractual measurements, a guard-banded rule reduces the risk of a bad instrument being accepted.
  • For production test equipment where false rejections are costly, you may accept slightly more risk in exchange for fewer unnecessary adjustments.

At PME Laboratory we apply simple acceptance by default, report all uncertainties, and clearly flag any result where the uncertainty straddles the limit. If you need a guard-banded rule, tell us when you place the order and we will agree it in writing.

Start a calibration

Your next calibration is due sooner than you think.

Send us your instrument list and we will come back within one working day with a fixed quote, turnaround date and collection slot.